About
New York City Pizza brings classic New York‐style pizza and Italian comfort food to Hilton Head Island, serving up fresh, flavorful pies and familiar favorites with a local twist. Since becoming a community mainstay in 1996, NYCP has been known for its authentic thin-crust pizza, hearty subs, pastas, and family-friendly atmosphere — all made with 100 % natural ingredients and house-made sauces and dough prepared fresh daily.
Location
You’ll find New York City Pizza at two great spots on the island:
- Heritage Plaza (South End): 81 Pope Ave, a convenient location near Coligny Beach and busy island neighborhoods — perfect for lunch or dinner any day of the week.
- Festival Centre (North End): 45 Pembroke Drive, Suite 105, in one of the island’s bustling shopping areas with plenty of parking and outdoor seating available.
Both locations offer easy delivery, takeout, and space for casual sit-downs without reservations, making them ideal stops before or after a beach day or island outing.
Must-Try Menu Items
New York City Pizza’s menu delivers classic Italian-American favorites alongside its signature pizzas:
- Classic New York-Style Pizza: Thin crust with tangy tomato sauce and melty mozzarella — simple, satisfying, and perfect by the slice or pie.
- Specialty Pizzas: Try the Meat Lovers, Margherita, BBQ Chicken, or Vegetarian for a more loaded slice experience.
- Deep Dish Pan Pizza: For a thicker, chewier crust and hearty toppings.
- Fried Calamari & Italian Fries: Tasty starters to share before your main dish.
- Subs & Wraps: Classic Italian subs like the Italian or Turkey and Provolone — great if you’re craving something other than pizza.
- Pasta & More: For a comforting meal, pastas and salads round out the menu.
Unique Features
What makes NYCP stand out on Hilton Head:
- Fresh, All-Natural Ingredients: Everything from dough to sauces is made in-house daily with no preservatives.
- Multiple Island Locations: Two convenient spots (North End & South End) make it easy to grab great pizza wherever you are on the island.
- Casual, Family-Friendly Dining: Relaxed indoor seating, takeout, and delivery options fit every kind of visit — from kid-friendly lunches to laid-back dinners with friends.
- Event & Group Friendly: Both locations have ample space for groups, celebrations, or casual gatherings without the fuss of reservations.
Vibe
New York City Pizza has a welcoming, no-frills vibe that feels like your favorite neighborhood pizza joint. Whether you’re grabbing a slice with family after the beach or ordering a pie to share with friends during game night, the atmosphere is relaxed and social. Locals appreciate its consistency and familiar flavors, and visitors often choose it for comfort food that hits the spot without breaking the bank. While opinions vary on how it stacks up against other local pizza spots, many enjoy its classic pizza and friendly service as part of the Hilton Head dining scene
